XtoysToosh Silicone Butt Plug Set of 3 Review: A Graduated Starter Kit
Editor's opinion
This is a sensible graduated set for anyone approaching anal play for the first time, or wanting a familiar shape across three sizes. The small is genuinely gentle, and the shared design keeps the feel consistent as you progress. The main caveat is the ABS jewelled base, which is a decorative feature rather than a comfort one.
Buying a single butt plug means committing to one size before you know what suits you. The Toosh Silicone Butt Plug Set sidesteps that by giving you small, medium and large in one box, all built to the same shape so the experience stays familiar as you move up.
The appeal here is progression. Rather than guessing, you can start with the smallest and work upward over time, or simply pick a size by mood. What matters when weighing this set is the size steps themselves, the material and its care needs, and whether the jewelled base is a bonus or a compromise.
The good and the bad
What works
- Three graduated sizes let you progress without guessing
- Small size (2.8 cm wide) is genuinely beginner-appropriate
- Consistent shape across all three keeps the feel familiar
- Silicone body is body-safe and easy to wipe clean
- Wide flared bases for safe, secure use
What to be aware of
- Silicone restricts you to water-based lubricant only
- ABS jewelled base is decorative rather than ergonomic
- Largest size at 4.4 cm wide is a real step up, not a casual one
- Jewel set into a hard base may catch attention on hygiene
Buy it if
Newcomers to anal play who want to start gentle and build confidence gradually, and anyone who likes having a range of sizes to choose from depending on the day.
Skip it if
Experienced users after a single large or heavily textured plug should look elsewhere, as should anyone wanting a fully silicone one-piece design without a hard base.
Design And Materials
Each plug pairs a smooth silicone body with an ABS plastic base, and it is worth understanding what that split means. The silicone portion is the part that matters most for comfort and safety: it is body-safe, non-porous and pleasant against skin. The ABS base carries the clear jewelled stone, which is purely a decorative touch.
The practical consequence of the silicone body is that you must use only water-based lubricant. Silicone lubricants can degrade silicone toys over time, so keep them away from this set. The hard ABS base is where the jewel sits flush, so pay attention to the join when cleaning, as any seam between materials is where residue can gather.
The Three Sizes And How They Step Up
The small measures 6.5 cm insertable and 2.8 cm wide, which is a genuinely modest starting point suitable for a first plug. The medium moves to 7 cm insertable and 3.5 cm wide, a meaningful but manageable increase. The large reaches 8.3 cm insertable and 4.4 cm wide at 80g.
That jump to the large is worth flagging. Going from 3.5 cm to 4.4 cm in width is a considerable increase, and the large is not somewhere to rush to. Used as intended, over time and with patience, the graduated approach is exactly what makes this format sensible. Treated as three interchangeable options, the largest will feel like a leap.
Temperature Play And Cleaning
Silicone holds temperature well, which is why the set is described as suited to warming or cooling before use. If you try this, always check the plug is comfortable to the touch first, and warm or cool gently rather than at extremes. The ABS base and the set jewel mean submerging in very hot or icy water is not advisable, so err on the side of caution.
Cleaning is straightforward thanks to the smooth surface. Wash before and after use with warm water and a suitable toy cleaner, paying particular attention to the base and around the jewel where the two materials meet. Because the base is not one continuous piece of silicone, thorough drying and storage matter.
How It Compares
Against a single plug bought in isolation, a graduated set is the safer buy for a beginner because it removes the guesswork on size. Against a fully silicone one-piece plug with an integrated base, this set trades a little on comfort and hygiene simplicity in exchange for the decorative jewel and the range of sizes.
If a jewelled aesthetic appeals and you value having options, this format delivers well. If you would rather have a single seamless silicone plug with no hard base, or you already know your preferred size, a dedicated single toy may serve you better.
The bottom line
For someone new to anal play, or anyone who wants a familiar shape across three sizes, this is a well-judged and body-safe set that supports gradual progression. Just go in knowing the base is hard ABS rather than silicone, that only water-based lubricant is appropriate, and that the largest size is a destination to build towards rather than a starting point.
Frequently asked questions
Is this set suitable for a complete beginner?
Yes. The small plug is 2.8 cm wide with a tapered tip and a modest insertable length, making it an appropriate starting point. The graduated format is designed precisely so you can build up gradually rather than committing to one size.
What lubricant should I use?
Only water-based lubricant. The silicone body can be degraded by silicone-based lubricants over time, so stick to water-based to protect the toys. Anal play in particular benefits from a generous amount of lubricant.
Can I really use these for temperature play?
Silicone holds temperature well, so you can warm or cool the plugs before use. Do so gently and always check the plug is comfortable to the touch first. Because of the ABS base and set jewel, avoid extreme heat or cold.
How do I keep the jewelled base clean?
Wash before and after each use with warm water and a suitable toy cleaner, taking care around the join where the silicone meets the ABS base and jewel. That seam is where residue can gather, so dry thoroughly before storing.
Do I need batteries or charging?
No. These are non-vibrating manual plugs with no power requirement, so there is nothing to charge or replace.